MLB · daily card archive

MLB picks for Tuesday, May 12, 2026

The Daily Picks Free model card. Graded at the posted line, flat 1u. Today’s MLB card · MLB record

3W 2L 5 graded picks

Pick of the Day · Tue, May 12

Philadelphia Phillies @ Boston Red Sox

Boston Red Sox

Line: +124 Slight edge 2-1 Final L

Boston Red Sox (home) - season-to-date numbers show a slight lean over Philadelphia Phillies. Early-season: win % held closer to a toss-up until samples grow. Calibrated vs 672 graded results.

Share on X

PICK #2 Detroit Tigers Detroit Tigers @ New York Mets

+128 Slight edge L

Detroit Tigers (away) - season-to-date numbers show a slight lean over New York Mets. Early-season: win % held closer to a toss-up until samples grow. Calibrated vs 672 graded results.

PICK #3 St. Louis Cardinals St. Louis Cardinals @ Athletics

+126 Slight edge W

St. Louis Cardinals (away) - season-to-date numbers show a slight lean over Athletics. Early-season: win % held closer to a toss-up until samples grow. Calibrated vs 672 graded results.

PICK #4 Tampa Bay Rays Tampa Bay Rays @ Toronto Blue Jays

-126 Slight edge W

Tampa Bay Rays (away) - season-to-date numbers show a slight lean over Toronto Blue Jays. Early-season: win % held closer to a toss-up until samples grow. Calibrated vs 672 graded results.

PICK #5 New York Yankees New York Yankees @ Baltimore Orioles

-164 Slight edge W

New York Yankees (away) - season-to-date numbers show a slight lean over Baltimore Orioles. Early-season: win % held closer to a toss-up until samples grow. Calibrated vs 672 graded results.

MLB & baseball on Kalshi: Open Kalshi (referral)

How to read the card: edge · flat units · variance · more.

Get on the list

One list for every sport. We’ll email when the free-pick email and Pro launch — neither is live yet. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.